Conflict of Interest
Jurnal Mettek: Jurnal Ilmiah Nasional dalam Bidang Ilmu Teknik Mesin is committed to maintaining transparency, objectivity, and integrity throughout the editorial and peer-review process. In alignment with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines, all participants in the publication process—authors, peer reviewers, and editors—must disclose any potential or actual conflicts of interest that could inappropriately influence, or be perceived to influence, their judgment or actions.
1. Definition of Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest (competing interest) occurs when professional judgment concerning a primary interest (such as the validity of mechanical engineering research or the objectivity of peer review) may be influenced by a secondary interest. Conflicts of interest may be:
-
Financial: Research grants, industrial sponsorships, equipment or material donations, consultancy fees, employment, stock ownership, honoraria, or patent applications/royalties related to the engineering technologies, materials, or software evaluated in the manuscript.
-
Non-Financial (Personal, Academic, or Institutional): Personal relationships, academic rivalry, direct institutional affiliation with the authors, or strong ideological/professional beliefs that could bias objective evaluation.
2. Responsibilities of Authors
-
Mandatory Disclosure Statement: All authors must disclose any financial or non-financial conflicts of interest upon submission. Every published manuscript must include a Conflict of Interest Statement prior to the reference list. If no conflicts exist, authors must explicitly state: "The authors declare no conflict of interest."
-
Funding Acknowledgment: Authors must clearly identify all funding sources (including grant numbers and industrial sponsors) that supported the research, and state whether the funder played any role in the study design, experimental testing, data interpretation, or decision to publish.
3. Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers
-
Pre-Review Disclosure: Invited reviewers must inform the Section Editor or Editor-in-Chief immediately if they have any conflict of interest with the manuscript, its authors (even in double-blind review, if the reviewer suspects the authors' identity), or competing commercial/academic interests.
-
Recusal: Reviewers must decline the invitation to review if they:
-
Have collaborated with, co-authored with, or supervised any of the authors within the past 3 years.
-
Belong to the same department or institution as the authors.
-
Have a direct financial or competitive stake in the engineering product, software, or methodology evaluated in the manuscript.
-
4. Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Board Members
-
Editorial Recusal: Editors and Editorial Board members must recuse themselves from handling, assigning reviewers to, or making decisions on any manuscript in which they have a personal, financial, or institutional conflict of interest (including manuscripts submitted by colleagues from their own department or recent research collaborators). Such manuscripts will be reassigned to another independent Section Editor or Guest Editor.
-
Submissions by Editorial Board Members: Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, Section Editors, or Editorial Board members are permitted, provided they undergo the exact same double-blind peer-review process managed independently by an uninvolved editor, with full transparency noted in the published article.
5. Handling Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest
If an undisclosed conflict of interest is discovered after submission or publication, Jurnal Mettek will follow COPE procedures to investigate the matter. Depending on the severity and impact on the research findings, the editorial board may reject the manuscript, publish a formal Corrigendum disclosing the competing interest, or issue a Retraction if the undisclosed conflict significantly compromised the integrity of the work.
