Research Misconduct

Jurnal Mettek: Jurnal Ilmiah Nasional dalam Bidang Ilmu Teknik Mesin upholds the highest standards of publication ethics and scientific integrity. In accordance with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines, the journal enforces a strict zero-tolerance policy toward all forms of research and publication misconduct.

1. Definition of Research Misconduct

Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to, the following unethical practices in mechanical engineering research and scholarly publishing:

  • Fabrication: Making up experimental measurements, simulation outputs (e.g., CFD/FEA results), material testing data, or equipment specifications and reporting them as genuine findings.

  • Falsification: Manipulating research materials, testing equipment, experimental processes, or changing/omitting data, graphs, or micrographs (such as SEM/optical microscopy images) such that the research is not accurately represented in the record.

  • Plagiarism & Self-Plagiarism: Appropriating another person’s ideas, mathematical models, engineering designs, processes, results, or words without proper attribution. This also includes text recycling (self-plagiarism), where authors reuse substantial portions of their own previously published works without citation.

  • Redundant / Duplicate Publication: Submitting the same manuscript—or manuscripts describing essentially the same research findings—simultaneously to more than one journal, or republishing previously published data without transparency and editorial permission.

  • Citation Manipulation: Artificially inflating citation counts through excessive self-citation, honorary citations, or coercive citation practices.

  • Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest: Failing to disclose financial, institutional, or personal relationships that could inappropriately bias or influence the research design, data interpretation, or peer-review process.

2. Screening and Detection

  • Similarity Check: Every submitted manuscript undergoes automated similarity screening using Turnitin / iThenticate prior to peer review. Manuscripts with a similarity index exceeding 20% (or showing unattributed block copying) will be returned to the authors or rejected outright.

  • Image & Data Verification: Editors and peer reviewers scrutinize figures, spectral plots, simulation contours, and experimental datasets for signs of digital alteration, duplication, or statistical anomalies. Authors may be required to submit raw experimental or simulation data upon editorial request.

3. Handling Allegations and Sanctions

When suspected misconduct is identified during peer review or after publication, Jurnal Mettek follows COPE flowcharts to investigate the matter fairly and confidentially:

  1. Initial Investigation: The Editor-in-Chief will contact the corresponding author to request a formal written explanation and supporting raw data.

  2. Institutional Notification: If the explanation is unsatisfactory or misconduct is confirmed, the editorial board may notify the authors' affiliated institution, university ethics committee, or funding agency.

  3. Editorial Actions: Depending on the severity of the violation, Jurnal Mettek reserves the right to:

    • Immediately reject the submitted manuscript.

    • Issue a formal Expression of Concern, Correction (Erratum/Corrigendum), or Retraction for already published articles, permanently linked to the original article record.

    • Impose a submission ban on the offending author(s) for a period of 2 to 5 years (or permanently for severe offenses).