Correction and Retraction
Jurnal Mettek: Jurnal Ilmiah Nasional dalam Bidang Ilmu Teknik Mesin is committed to maintaining the accuracy, completeness, and integrity of the scholarly record. In accordance with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines, the journal establishes clear procedures for handling post-publication amendments, corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.
1. Corrections (Erratum and Corrigendum)
Corrections are issued when a significant error is identified in a published article that affects the clarity or accuracy of the publication record, but does not invalidate the fundamental scientific findings or conclusions of the study.
-
Erratum (Publisher Error): Issued when an error was introduced during the editorial, typesetting, or production process by the Jurnal Mettek editorial team (e.g., missing equations, corrupted figures, incorrect author affiliations, or formatting errors).
-
Corrigendum (Author Error): Issued when an honest, unintentional error was made by the authors (e.g., typographical mistakes in mathematical formulas, mislabeled experimental parameters, or minor calculation errors) that does not alter the overall validity of the research.
Procedure: Upon verification by the Editor-in-Chief, a formal correction notice is published in the next available issue, detailing the exact changes made and permanently linked bidirectionally to the original article via its DOI (Crossref).
2. Expression of Concern
An Expression of Concern may be issued by the Editor-in-Chief to alert readers when:
-
There is inconclusive or preliminary evidence of research or publication misconduct (such as data manipulation or authorship disputes) involving a published article.
-
An institutional or editorial investigation is ongoing and will take considerable time to reach a definitive conclusion.
-
Concerns exist regarding the reliability of the engineering data or methodology, while the authors' institution declines or is unable to investigate the matter.
Once the investigation concludes, the Expression of Concern will be replaced or updated with either a formal Retraction or an exoneration notice.
3. Retraction
A Retraction is issued when clear evidence shows that the findings of a published article are unreliable or unethical, whether due to honest major error or intentional research misconduct. Grounds for retraction include, but are not limited to:
-
Unreliable Findings: Major experimental flaws, miscalculations, or erroneous numerical simulations (e.g., CFD/FEA setup errors) that invalidate the core conclusions.
-
Data Fabrication or Falsification: Evidence of manipulated experimental measurements, altered microscopy/testing images, or fabricated datasets.
-
Plagiarism or Duplicate Publication: Confirmed substantial plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or prior publication of the same work without disclosure or permission.
-
Unethical Research: Failure to disclose major conflicts of interest or breaches of research ethics that significantly compromised the study.
Retraction Process & Archival Integrity:
-
Retractions may be requested by the authors or initiated by the Editor-in-Chief following a COPE-compliant investigation.
-
A formal Retraction Notice—clearly stating the title, authors, reason(s) for retraction, and who initiated the action—is published and linked to the original article via Crossref/DOI.
-
To preserve the historical scholarly record, retracted articles are not deleted from the Jurnal Mettek archive. Instead, the original PDF and HTML versions are retained with a prominent "RETRACTED" watermark on every page, accompanied by a direct link to the Retraction Notice.
4. Article Removal (Exceptional Circumstances)
Complete removal of an article from the online portal occurs only under extreme legal or safety circumstances, such as:
-
The article is clearly defamatory or infringes upon third-party legal rights.
-
The article is subject to a court order.
-
The reported mechanical engineering process or material poses a severe, immediate hazard to public health or safety if acted upon.
In such cases, the article's metadata (title and authors) is retained on the webpage with a formal statement explaining why the full text was removed.
