Post Publication Discussion
Jurnal Mettek: Jurnal Ilmiah Nasional dalam Bidang Ilmu Teknik Mesin welcomes constructive scholarly debate and critical engagement with published articles to foster transparency, scientific rigor, and ongoing advancement in mechanical engineering research.
1. Channels for Post-Publication Discussion
Readers, researchers, and practitioners may engage with published articles through two primary channels:
-
Letters to the Editor / Technical Comments: Readers who wish to offer substantive technical commentary, alternative engineering interpretations, methodological critiques, or supplementary experimental/numerical findings regarding an article published in Jurnal Mettek may submit a formal Letter to the Editor (or Technical Comment) via the journal's Open Journal Systems (OJS) portal or directly to the editorial office (
mesins2@unud.ac.id). -
Direct Author Correspondence: For routine clarifications, data inquiries, or academic collaboration, readers are encouraged to contact the designated Corresponding Author directly using the contact details provided on the published article.
2. Review and Publication of Technical Comments
To maintain scholarly quality, all formal post-publication submissions are subject to editorial evaluation:
-
Editorial Screening: The Editor-in-Chief and relevant Section Editor assess whether the commentary raises valid, evidence-based technical points relevant to the published work. Submissions containing personal attacks, defamatory remarks, or unsubstantiated claims will be declined.
-
Author Right of Reply: If a Letter to the Editor or Technical Comment is deemed suitable for publication, the original authors will be invited to submit a formal Author Reply within a specified timeframe (typically 30 days).
-
Peer Review & Publication: Both the commentary and the authors' response may undergo peer review before being published together in an upcoming issue, permanently linked to the original article via Crossref/DOI metadata.
3. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
If post-publication discussions uncover verifiable errors, methodological flaws, or ethical breaches that affect the integrity or conclusions of a published paper, Jurnal Mettek follows Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines to issue appropriate post-publication notices:
-
Erratum / Corrigendum: Published for honest errors (such as typographical mistakes in equations, mislabeled figures, or minor calculation errors) that do not invalidate the core scientific conclusions of the article.
-
Expression of Concern: Issued when inconclusive evidence of research or publication misconduct arises and an investigation is underway.
-
Retraction: Issued when major scientific errors, fabricated/falsified data, or ethical violations invalidate the findings of the published article. Retracted articles remain accessible in the archive with a clear "RETRACTED" watermark and an explanatory notice linked to the record.
